City News
  • Church
    • Church & Missions
    • 中文报道
    • Harvest Magazine
    • 《丰收》纪念特刊
  • Features
  • Interviews
  • Culture
    • CityFamilies
    • Community
    • Eye On Society
    • Lifestyle
  • Perspective
  • Who We Are
  • Who We Are

City News

  • Church
    • Church & Missions
    • 中文报道
    • Harvest Magazine
    • 《丰收》纪念特刊
  • Features
  • Interviews
  • Culture
    • CityFamilies
    • Community
    • Eye On Society
    • Lifestyle
  • Perspective
  • Who We Are
BlogPerspective

CN Blog – My Thoughts On The City Harvest Appeal

By Theresa Tan September 23, 2016September 25, 2018
By Theresa Tan September 23, 2016September 25, 2018

Teo Hsin Yi, a member of City Harvest Church since its beginning, attended the Court of Appeal last Wednesday. She shares her honest thoughts on what she observed.

My Thoughts On The City Harvest Appeal

Thousands of young people at a Crossover concert in Taiwan.

On Sep 21, the last day of the appeals from the City Harvest team and the prosecution, I sat in the Court of Appeal listening intently to very technical arguments over “genuine or sham” investments, control and bond investments. Each time the DPP said the words, “having caused wrongful loss to the church”, something inside me desperately wanted to say out loud, “No, you don’t understand.”

I held this silent exasperation within my heart until Pastor Tan Ye Peng’s lawyer, senior counsel N. Sreenivasan stood up and started his replies. The “God moment” came in his opening statement. Instead of going headlong into his arguments, he appealed to the three High Court judges to consider the great dissonance (the inconsistency between the beliefs one holds or between one’s actions and one’s beliefs) in mindsets between the people outside the church and those within.

Mr Sreenivasan earnestly appealed to the judges to take a step back to understand that the way the church thinks and makes decisions may seem rather illogical to those outside the church, but that did not mean that they are wrong. He cited an example of how, when he saw his mother performing Hindu rites, his educated mind did not agree, yet the fact remained that she was not wrong in what she believed and did.

Then Mr Sreenivasan told the judges something that introduced a rare breath of humanity into the cold courtroom. He related how he had, at the start of the trial, visited our church service and how what he saw and heard gave him a glimpse into what had gone on in the minds of the accused when they made certain decisions concerning the Crossover.

The lawyer added that those outside the church should not use their yardstick to measure our intent and actions. He admitted that CHC’s way was not easy to accept, but three years on, it’s all beginning to feel more comfortable. He said something like “This was the world they (the appellants) lived in, since they were 16.”

My heart was moved. Here was a man who did not share the same faith as us, yet he spoke with such genuine understanding.

Perhaps it was God’s way of reminding me that He is still the one who searches the heart and tests the mind of every man. Putting aside religious beliefs, we all have a conscience that can tell between right and wrong, good and evil. The court may demand black and white evidence to prove dishonesty or the absence of it, but in my limited layman’s mind, sometimes all it takes is perhaps what Atticus told Scout in Harper Lee’s novel To Kill A Mockingbird.

“First of all,” he said, “if you can learn a simple trick, Scout, you’ll get along a lot better with all kinds of folks. You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view […] until you climb into his skin and walk around in it.”

As the court session ended, I hope that those from the outside would make an attempt to walk in our skin and, perhaps, see that in the light of eternity, the Crossover was never a loss but a gain.

CHCCHC TrialCrossover Project
0
FacebookTwitterWhatsappTelegram
Theresa Tan

Theresa Tan is the Senior Editor of City News. God gave Theresa one talent: the gift of writing. She has done her best to multiply her talent by writing articles for newspapers and magazines, plays, screenplays and a book. But what gives her greatest joy is using her one talent to serve the Lord in City News, by spreading the Good News. Theresa is blissfully married with three children and two cats. She loves reading, knitting, watching Korean criminal dramas and training young writers to win the world with words.

Related Articles

THN Malaysia Conference: Flowing In The Same Spirit

May 19, 2023

Spiritual Disciplines Series: Fasting

May 18, 2023

Young Adults Retreat: Experiencing Koinonia

May 12, 2023

Looking Back On CHC At Hollywood Theatre: Singlehood...

May 6, 2023

CHC Turns 33: The Joys Of Working In...

May 12, 2022

20 Years After The Crossover Project

April 22, 2022

Letters From New Citizens: Happy Birthday Singapore!

August 8, 2021

The Person God Can Use: Wu Yuzhuang

March 23, 2021

Fasting And Prayer Testimony: My Parents Received Salvation

November 18, 2020

“To Teach Is To Care”: Bernard Ricardo, Caring...

September 29, 2020

Cookout with Pastor Yong

Chap Chye



Claypot Rice



Osmanthus Jelly



Hainanese Pork Chop

City News Weekly

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Youtube

© City News. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Notice | Terms